Should the gubmint build a social network?
2008.07.31 @ 21:22Hot off the presses, I ruminate on the idea of a government-erected social network. (Watch me experience SYNTAX ERROR at the six minute mark when I think for a moment that I may have forgotten to click “record”!)
Background reading:
A. Social norms go bye-bye
‘melting the solids’ left the whole complex network of social relations unstuck
– Sociologist Zygmunt Bauman in his 2000 Liquid Modernity
As quoted in my 7/21/2008 post: Has our composition of interactions shifted away from social norms towards market norms?
B. Peeps use thug calculus when making decisions
… teenage delinquents could really care less if stealing that old lady’s handbag is going to hurt their chances at getting into college. Applying to college is three years away; $20 and a crusty tube of lip balm is three seconds away: “I need to get some cash right now!” not “I need to maximize lifetime earning potential.” The timeframe over which mental calculus is conducted is significantly shorter for the teenage delinquent and their behaviors and actions crescendo accordingly.
From my 7/1/2008 post: Are middle managers like teenage delinquents?
C. Taxes = Club USA membership dues
Membership benefits include a stable financial system, air quality that’s better than Mexico City, and a buncha other stuff. But I’ve never looked at my taxes this way, and I’ve gotta say … man, that’s a lotta taxes.
From my 4/14/2006 post: Aren’t taxes simply membership benefits?
My line of thinking regarding the government erection of a social network is loosely organized as follows:
- We do not interact with our fellow citizens in the way we did 25 years ago, in part due to technology
- As a result, social capital gained from the walking neighborhood has plummeted, arguably resulting in increased demand for social services
- This drop in social capital has resulted in suboptimal decision making on an individual level which, in aggregate, negatively impacts society / increases my taxes
- Could the government launch a CLUB US and A social network to attempt to replenish the lost social capital, with the end goal being a more efficient use of public funds (by decreasing the need for social services and replacing top-down community policing with socially normative, flat community policing) ?
Curious to hear what y’all sink about siss.




